The Diesel Surprise: After 2500 km Across Europe, Electric Cars Still Can’t Beat It on Cost

Show summary Hide summary

• A Long Road Trip Starts at Tesla’s Door
• Charging Up: Coffee Breaks, Not Just for Drivers
• And the Winner Is… Still Wearing Diesel Cologne
• More Choices Than Ever—A Win for Everyone

Think electric cars have finally taken the throne when it comes to long-distance cost savings? Think again. A 2,500-kilometre journey from Berlin to Madrid set out to pit electric vehicles against their internal combustion cousins. The result: diesel is still the reigning champion of wallet-friendly travel across Europe. Turns out, the future isn’t always as straightforward—and sometimes, it still smells a bit like diesel.

A Long Road Trip Starts at Tesla’s Door

The journey began with a stop at the Tesla Gigafactory in Berlin, a place where electricity practically hums through the walls and you half-expect robots to invite you for a cup of coffee. From there, a group of journalists hit the open road to Spain’s capital, Madrid. Their chariots: two electric heavyweights, the Model Y Long Range RWD and the Model 3 Highland Long Range. Both are stars in the electric world, boasting enough futuristic features to make you wonder if you’ll accidentally trigger autopilot just by looking at them.

Charging Up: Coffee Breaks, Not Just for Drivers

Planning the route wasn’t left to chance. The Tesla integrated navigation system took the wheel (figuratively, we promise) when it came to scheduling charging stops. The system prioritised Tesla’s own Superchargers but could also find charging stations from other operators—a little cross-network cooperation never hurt anyone. On average, pit stops occurred every 200 to 300 kilometres. These weren’t merely for the sake of the cars: they also became an excuse for a coffee fix or a swift break.

• Charging sessions often ended before the batteries were at 100%, making the most of the drivers’ need for a stretch rather than the battery’s plea for full charge.
• Stops were timed more for convenience and comfort than strict necessity.

But what’s fair is fair. Just to keep the contest honest, the journalists simulated the same route with both a petrol car (with a consumption of 7 litres per 100 km) and a diesel car (with 5.5 litres per 100 km). They used average prices supplied by the European Union for their calculations, giving every contestant a level financial playing field.

And the Winner Is… Still Wearing Diesel Cologne

What did all these carefully measured kilometres, caffeine-fuelled stops, and battery management ultimately demonstrate? The numbers spoke, and they showed something few would shout about in an electric showroom: in terms of overall cost, diesel vehicles still come out on top for a trip like this. Yes, even alongside all the silent acceleration and futuristic dashboards of electric vehicles.

Of course, the contest isn’t entirely black and white—or should we say, high voltage and low CO2? For some, speed is king—getting from Berlin to Madrid as quickly as possible matters most. For others, it’s the operating costs that cause the most headache relief (or pain, depending on your maths). And then there’s the crowd who value the environmental impact above all else, for whom the sound of silence beats the roar of the internal combustion engine every time.

• Fastest journey: Not always the electric car’s territory.
• Lowest cost: Diesel still has its day in the sun.
• Biggest green credentials: The electric crowd takes this one, no contest.

More Choices Than Ever—A Win for Everyone

Here’s where optimism enters the picture. Today’s car market looks nothing like it did a decade ago. There’s no longer just one right answer. The options are wide and varied—meaning just about every driver can find a vehicle that fits their own lifestyle like a glove. You can juggle performance, cost, and sustainability according to your own priorities—and let’s be honest, that’s not a bad place to be.

So whether you’re a road trip warrior counting every cent, an eco-enthusiast saving the planet one silent kilometre at a time, or just enjoy a good coffee at every rest stop, the horizon is wide open. The journey continues—and the debate isn’t running out of fuel anytime soon.