Revealed: The Most and Least Reliable Car Brands of 2024—Japanese Models Dominate the Rankings

Show summary Hide summary

• How Reliability Was Judged: The Nuts, Bolts, and Surprises
• The 2024 Podium: Japan and South Korea Shift Into High Gear
• The Shaky End of the Chart: Has Your Favorite Made the Naughty List?
• How to Use These Scores Without Losing Sleep—or Your Afternoon at the Garage

Thinking about buying a car in 2024 and hoping to avoid the “check engine” light becoming your dashboard’s new best friend? Recent Dutch research reveals clear winners and, let’s be honest, a few underperformers in the ongoing car reliability contest—spoiler: the East keeps driving ahead of the West.

How Reliability Was Judged: The Nuts, Bolts, and Surprises

This latest reliability ranking is no back-of-the-envelope job. Based on the annual car malfunction survey by the Consumentenbond, nearly 30,000 car owners from 33 brands, with cars up to ten years old, reported on the issues they encountered during the past year. Every problem was logged, but crucially, serious breakdowns were weighted more heavily than small annoyances. The outcome? A crystal-clear risk-o-meter for anyone wanting to steer clear of unexpected breakdowns, not just whimper about squeaky glove boxes.

The methodology exposed a consistent trend: Japanese and South Korean brands outperform most of their European rivals structurally—not just sometimes, but year after year. That’s good news if your shortlist features some Asian contenders, and a clue for those reconsidering their European loyalties.

The 2024 Podium: Japan and South Korea Shift Into High Gear

The leaderboard leaves no room for doubt. Lexus not only takes pole position—it essentially laps the field with a score of 9.6. That’s not just winning; that’s high-fiving the engineers all the way to the bank. Hot on Lexus’s tail are Suzuki, Subaru, and Toyota. Rounding out the top ten:

• Kia (8.5)
• Smart (8.5)
• Honda (8.3)
• Mitsubishi (8.3)
• Nissan (8.1)
• BMW (8.0)

The pattern is clear: Asian brands dominate the reliability scene right now, with BMW as an honorable European interloper. AutoRAI laid out the complete ranking in a clear overview, spotlighting the top-scoring models for those determined to turn research into reality.

For the shopping-minded, here’s some extra help: the Mitsubishi ASX, Mazda CX-3, and Suzuki Vitara stand out as especially strong choices in this overview. Handy information for those after a used car that offers not just smooth driving but also predictable, drama-free maintenance. Who says you can’t have your cake and skip the tow truck too?

The Shaky End of the Chart: Has Your Favorite Made the Naughty List?

If you were about to put down a deposit on a Land Rover, brace yourself: it’s found itself at the very bottom this year, with a sobering 4.8. Opel follows a good distance away at 6.5. Further up the ladder are brands merged into duos or trios (due to insufficient data per brand): Citroën/Peugeot at 7.0, Ford/Lancia/Volkswagen at 7.1, and Renault/Škoda at 7.2.

It’s important to remember: these are averages across models and years. A strong model from a so-called “weaker” brand could still reward you with years of carefree transport. Autovisie underlines that Lexus undoubtedly stands alone at the top, tailed by Suzuki and Subaru, while the least reliable corner is crowded by the aforementioned brands.

How to Use These Scores Without Losing Sleep—or Your Afternoon at the Garage

Take these scores as a risk barometer—not doom-and-gloom for every individual car. The smart move? Combine the brand average with specific model and year data, check out the car’s maintenance history, and always schedule a pre-purchase inspection. Especially as 2025 approaches, when busy workshops and pricey parts make reliability matter more than ever, your brand choice can make a world of difference for your wallet, time, and peace of mind. For all the nitty-gritty details, including scores by brand and model plus the survey methodology, head straight to the Consumentenbond.

If you choose a brand from the top of the list, your chances of trouble noticeably drop. If, however, your heart is set on a “risk brand”, double down on your research for that specific model—it’s twice as rewarding. After all, the aim is to keep driving fun and your calendar blissfully free of unexpected garage visits. Isn’t that what we all want from our cars?